Create Account

Username
Password
Remember me
Email
 
22
evolution
evolution

Dogs Understand Pointing, Chimps Do Not

5 comments, 142 views, posted 3:21 am 05/02/2012 in Nature by evolution
evolution has 4870 posts, 1916 threads, 4665 points
Team Van Helsing

Tricpe's thread "funny gif" (link) prompted me to see if I could find any literature or video on canine intelligence, specifically their ability to understand the gesture of pointing, and I found this video. Watching it, I was surprised to learn that not only can dogs understand when a human being points with her hands, but they can also understand when a human "points" with her eyes.

Chimpanzees, in spite of being more intelligent than dogs, do not understand the gesture.

Extra Points Given by:

grnday3415 (5), bradpitt (10), Edorph (5)

Comments

0
3:23 am 05/02/2012

evolution

This, by the way, also raises the question, will a sentient extra-terrestrial species understand pointing? Will they understand any human gestures or body language at all?

Carl Sagan, by his own admittance, said that one of the shortcomings of the Pioneer Plaques is the use of an arrow to indicate the probes were launched from the third planet from the sun. Arrows seem intuitive to us because we descend from culture of hunter-gatherers. An intelligent extra-terrestrial species, however, may not understand the use of an arrow as pointing symbol if they did not evolve from a hunter-gatherer cultural heritage.

1
4:19 am 05/02/2012

grnday3415

There's a documentary on Netflix about this. It's called "Dogs Decoded".

0
4:22 am 05/02/2012

evolution

Is that where the Youtube clip is from? I would love to see the whole thing.

0
8:36 am 05/02/2012

marksyzm

Quote by evolution:


This, by the way, also raises the question, will a sentient extra-terrestrial species understand pointing? Will they understand any human gestures or body language at all?

Carl Sagan, by his own admittance, said that one of the shortcomings of the Pioneer Plaques is the use of an arrow to indicate the probes were launched from the third planet from the sun. Arrows seem intuitive to us because we descend from culture of hunter-gatherers. An intelligent extra-terrestrial species, however, may not understand the use of an arrow as pointing symbol if they did not evolve from a hunter-gatherer cultural heritage.

Any species would understand a triangle as a pointing symbol, but that one was far too cryptic

1
1:49 pm 05/02/2012

Quaektem

The real problem is they set back translation by at least fifty years by putting bobbies on it.

Add Comment

Log in via teoti, or register to add a comment!


Teh NookMayrHayasdanJaranWebAngryShirtsGoneGeekEat Liver